On 15 October 2026, the Court of Justice of the EU handed down a landmark ruling in Case C-70/25 (Tukowiecka) that will echo through UK consumer banking for years to come. The judgment established that banks must refund fraud victims—including those targeted by sophisticated phishing scams—by the end of the next business day, and only then can they investigate whether gross negligence played a role. This principle is now directly reflected in the FCA's Payment Services Regulations guidance, making it a watershed moment for anyone whose bank has refused to refund an authorised push payment (APP) fraud.
If your bank has told you "no" to a refund claim following APP fraud, you may feel powerless. But the law is now unambiguously on your side—and this guide will show you exactly how to fight back.
Understanding Your Legal Rights
APP fraud occurs when you are tricked or deceived into authorising a payment to a fraudster's account. You might be impersonated by someone claiming to be your bank, the police, HMRC, or a legitimate business. You authorise the transfer yourself—but the destination is fake. This is different from unauthorised fraud, where someone steals your details and moves money without your knowledge.
Until 7 October 2024, APP fraud victims had virtually no legal protection. The assumption was that if you authorised the payment, you were liable. That changed overnight with the introduction of the Authorised Push Payment Reimbursement Scheme, which is now written into the Payment Services Regulations 2017 (as amended) and enforced by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
Here is the core principle: your bank must reimburse you for APP fraud unless it can prove you acted with gross negligence or fraud yourself. The burden of proof has shifted decisively in your favour.
What the Law Actually Says
The Payment Services Regulations 2017 (Regulation 75E and Schedule 4A) now require all UK payment service providers (banks, building societies, fintech firms authorised to handle payments) to establish a mandatory reimbursement scheme for APP fraud victims. The FCA published detailed guidance in its Consumer Duty Sourcebook and Finalised Guidance (FG24/4) in March 2024, setting out precisely how banks must operate this scheme.
The scheme covers all payments made on or after 7 October 2024 using either Faster Payments or CHAPS (the two main UK payment networks). It applies to consumers, microenterprises (businesses with fewer than 10 employees and turnover under €2 million), and charities. Larger businesses are excluded.
Maximum reimbursement: £85,000 per claim. Banks can deduct a voluntary excess of up to £100 (except for vulnerable customers). The clock starts ticking from the moment you authorise the payment; you have 13 months to report the fraud to your bank, though reporting sooner is always advised.
When Payments Are NOT Covered
Be aware: the scheme does not cover payments sent overseas, internal transfers between your own accounts, or disputes that are purely civil in nature (such as a disagreement about the quality of goods purchased). If you sent money to an international bank account, or if the payment date was before 7 October 2024, you fall outside the mandatory scheme. However, you may still have rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 or under common law.
The Tukowiecka Ruling and What It Means for Your Bank's Refusal
The October 2026 Court Judgment
The EU Court of Justice's decision in Tukowiecka—decided just days before this guide was written—has profound implications for UK consumers. The court ruled that banks cannot use the "consumer standard of caution" (the gross negligence test) as a reason to delay reimbursement. Instead, the bank must reimburse immediately, and then investigate whether gross negligence occurred. In plain terms: you get your money back first, and the bank proves its case against you afterwards, not the other way around.
This reverses the historical burden of proof and aligns perfectly with the FCA's own guidance issued in March 2024. If your bank has refused to refund you, citing gross negligence or your failure to exercise "reasonable caution," this judgment directly undermines that refusal. The bank's job is to reimburse now and investigate later—not the reverse.
How This Changes Your Appeal
If you received a refusal letter from your bank, you can now cite Tukowiecka (Case C-70/25) in your response. The ruling establishes that:
- Reimbursement must happen by the end of the next business day after you report the fraud, unless the bank can immediately prove gross negligence.
- The bank cannot withhold funds pending investigation. Investigation happens after reimbursement, not before.
- "Gross negligence" requires a high bar: you must have ignored explicit warnings, failed to follow reasonable security practices you were aware of, or deliberately assisted the fraudster.
If your bank refused to refund and offered no evidence of gross negligence or fraud on your part, you now have a powerful legal weapon.
When Can Your Bank Actually Refuse to Reimburse?
Your bank is allowed to refuse reimbursement in only two circumstances: if you acted with fraud yourself, or if you acted with gross negligence. However, there are no automatic refusals based on the fact that you "should have been more careful."
The "Consumer Standard of Caution" Test
Gross negligence is defined in the Payment Services Regulations by reference to a "consumer standard of caution." This is a high bar—significantly higher than simple negligence. It requires that you breached conduct that a reasonable consumer in your position would have followed. The FCA guidance identifies four specific scenarios where gross negligence might apply:
- Ignoring explicit bank warnings: Your bank gave you a specific, clear warning that the transaction looked suspicious (e.g., it failed authentication checks, it was flagged by their fraud system), and you ignored that warning and completed the payment anyway.
- Failing to act on public fraud warnings: Relevant fraud warnings were publicly available from government agencies, law enforcement, or your bank's own website, and you had reasonable opportunity to be aware of them but proceeded anyway.
- Unreasonable delay in reporting: You became aware the payment was fraudulent but deliberately delayed reporting it to your bank, allowing the fraudster extra time to move or hide the money. (Note: delays caused by reporting directly to the police first are not held against you.)
- Refusing to cooperate with investigation: Your bank asked you to provide information to help trace the funds or investigate the fraud, and you refused without reasonable justification.
The Financial Services Authority released statistics from Q1 2025 showing that only 3% of APP fraud claims were rejected for failing to meet the consumer standard of caution. This tells you something important: banks are not routinely denying claims. If yours was refused, it is likely either that the bank made an error in applying the test, or that your case presents genuine complexity.
Vulnerable Customers Get Extra Protection
If you are classified as vulnerable (elderly, disabled, experiencing financial difficulty, or with limited digital literacy), your bank cannot apply the consumer standard of caution to your claim at all. You have an automatic right to reimbursement, and the excess cannot be deducted. If your bank refused your claim and you believe you meet the FCA's definition of vulnerable, this is a critical point in your appeal.
Write Your Formal Complaint Letter in 30 Seconds
Paybacker's AI generates complaint letters citing exact UK law. Free to try—3 letters per month, no credit card needed.
Generate Free LetterWhy Banks Refuse: Common Reasons and How to Challenge Them
"You Didn't Check the Recipient's Details"
This is the most common refusal reason. Your bank says you should have called the company directly before sending money, or checked the sort code, or verified the bank account holder's name against a third party. Frustratingly, this was often your only recourse before October 2024. Now, it's not enough to justify a refusal—unless your bank can show you ignored explicit warnings from them or publicly available government warnings. The consumer standard of caution does not require you to be a banking expert or to perform verification checks you were unaware of.
"You Fell for a Phishing Email / SMS"
Even if a fraudster impersonated your bank perfectly, or sent you a fake invoice from an ostensibly trusted supplier, you are still entitled to reimbursement. The Tukowiecka ruling explicitly covers phishing victims. Your bank cannot refuse simply because you "should have known it was a scam." The question is whether you acted with gross negligence—and falling for a sophisticated phishing attempt, standing alone, does not meet that threshold.
"You Sent Money Overseas"
This is a legitimate ground for refusal under the current scheme. The mandatory reimbursement rules only cover payments within the UK via Faster Payments or CHAPS. If you sent money to an international account (especially via SWIFT or a money transfer service), you fall outside the scheme. However, you may have other protections under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 or under common law, and Paybacker's letter templates can help you pursue those avenues.
"You Sent Money Before 7 October 2024"
Regrettably, the reimbursement scheme does not apply retroactively. If your payment went out before that date, you are not covered by the mandatory scheme. However, you may still lodge a complaint under the FCA's Consumer Duty or pursue a claim through the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) on the grounds that your bank failed in its duty of care.
Step-by-Step Guide to Challenging Your Bank's Refusal
Step 1: Gather Your Evidence
Before you draft a response, collect every piece of evidence that shows you acted reasonably. This includes:
- The email, SMS, letter, or phone call that tricked you into making the payment—save screenshots or forwards.
- Any warning messages from your bank (or the absence of them—banks often claim they warned you when they did not).
- The date you discovered the fraud and the date you reported it to your bank.
- Evidence of any police report (a crime reference number strengthens your case).
- Communications with your bank during the claim process—emails, call logs, letters.
- If you reported to the police first, evidence of that report (delays caused by police reporting do not count against you).
Step 2: Send a Formal Complaint to Your Bank
Your bank is required to have a formal complaints procedure. Write a clear, numbered letter that:
- References the Payment Services Regulations 2017 (specifically Regulation 75E and Schedule 4A).
- Cites the FCA's guidance (Finalised Guidance 24/4, March 2024), which mandates reimbursement of APP fraud.
- References Case C-70/25 (Tukowiecka), decided 15 October 2026, which establishes that reimbursement must occur before investigation of gross negligence.
- States clearly that you do not meet the consumer standard of caution because: (a) your bank provided no explicit warning, or (b) you were not aware of publicly available warnings, or (c) you reported promptly, or (d) you did not refuse to cooperate with investigation.
- Requests reimbursement of the full amount, less the £100 excess (unless you are vulnerable, in which case request the full amount).
- Gives the bank 10 working days to respond or escalate to their complaints team.
A well-drafted complaint letter citing the exact legislation makes a measurable difference. If you want to save time and ensure legal accuracy, Paybacker's AI complaints tool generates formal letters citing exact UK law in 30 seconds—and you can generate up to 3 letters per month free of charge.
Step 3: Request a Formal Response from the Complaints Department
Your bank's frontline team may have dismissed your claim, but the formal complaints department has different procedures and often reaches different conclusions. Insist on a "Final Response" letter (the formal term used under FCA rules). This letter must be issued within 8 weeks and must either uphold your complaint or set out precisely why they are refusing it and your right to escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
Step 4: Check If You Qualify as Vulnerable
The FCA defines vulnerable customers as those experiencing one or more of the following: age-related vulnerability, mental capacity or health issues, literacy or numeracy difficulties, low income, or isolation. If you tick any of these boxes, your bank cannot apply the consumer standard of caution. This dramatically strengthens your position. If you believe you are vulnerable, state this explicitly in your complaint and request that it be taken into account.
Step 5: Escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS)
If your bank issues a Final Response rejecting your claim, or if they fail to respond within 8 weeks, you can escalate to the Financial Ombudsman Service. The FOS is an independent regulator with power to order compensation up to £430,000. You have 6 months from the date of the bank's Final Response letter to escalate. The FOS will review whether your bank correctly applied the consumer standard of caution and whether the Tukowiecka ruling supports your case. There is no fee to use the FOS.
The FOS has already seen hundreds of APP fraud cases, and its case decisions increasingly favour consumers, particularly in phishing scenarios where the fraudster impersonated a trusted party and the victim acted reasonably.
Are Fraudulent Transactions Draining Your Account?
Connect your bank to Paybacker and our AI identifies every suspicious transaction and helps you dispute and recover them—then generates your formal complaint letter.
Scan My Bank FreeWhat If They Still Refuse After Escalation?
The Financial Ombudsman Service Route
As mentioned above, the FOS is your most direct escalation path. When you raise a complaint with the FOS, they will ask your bank to provide evidence of gross negligence or fraud on your part. The burden is on the bank, not you. You must provide your account of what happened and copies of any evidence (emails, screenshots, police reports). The FOS will then adjudicate, and its decisions are legally binding on the bank. If the FOS awards compensation, the bank must pay within a set timeframe (usually 28 days).
Trading Standards and the FCA
If you believe your bank has breached the FCA's Consumer Duty (which requires firms to act honestly, fairly, and professionally, and to put consumer interests first), you can also report the matter to Trading Standards or directly to the FCA's Consumer Duty team. These are complementary channels to the FOS complaint, not alternatives. Trading Standards can investigate whether the bank's behaviour breaches consumer protection law. The FCA may issue guidance or enforcement action if a pattern of breaches emerges.
Small Claims Court
If the claim is relatively small (under £10,000 in England and Wales, under £5,000 in Scotland), you can bring a Small Claims Court action against your bank for breach of contract or breach of statutory duty under the Payment Services Regulations. This route requires more formality than the FOS but may be appropriate if your bank is being particularly obstructive or if the sum is above the FOS limit of £430,000. You can pursue this in parallel with an FOS complaint. Many consumers find this threat alone encourages banks to settle.
Pursuing a formal debt collection response if your bank threatens enforcement
Some banks, after refusing an APP fraud claim, later pursue the consumer for the "debt" via third-party debt collectors. If this happens to you, you have rights under the Consumer Credit Act 1974 and the Limitation Act 1980. Do not ignore debt collection letters. Respond with a formal defence citing the APP Reimbursement Scheme and the bank's obligation to reimburse. Paybacker's debt letter response tool can help you draft this in minutes.
Key Facts at a Glance
- Start date: The APP Reimbursement Scheme came into force on 7 October 2024. Only payments made on or after this date are covered.
- Maximum refund: £85,000 per claim (not £415,000 as originally proposed).
- Excess: Up to £100 can be deducted by your bank, except for vulnerable customers.
- Time to reimburse: By the end of the next business day after you report the fraud (per Tukowiecka, October 2026).
- Deadline to report: 13 months from the last payment. Reporting sooner is always better.
- Burden of proof: The bank must prove gross negligence or fraud on your part. You are presumed to be honest unless proven otherwise.
- Gross negligence threshold: Very high. Simple negligence or "you should have been more careful" does not suffice. The bank must show you ignored explicit warnings, failed to act on public warnings you knew about, delayed reporting, or refused to cooperate.
- Vulnerable customers: The consumer standard of caution does not apply. Automatic reimbursement, no excess.
- Overseas payments: Not covered. Only Faster Payments and CHAPS within the UK.
- Phishing and impersonation: Covered. Tukowiecka confirms phishing victims are entitled to reimbursement.
- FOS award limit: £430,000. The FOS can award compensation beyond the £85,000 scheme cap if the bank has acted unfairly.
- Bank's obligation if you report to police first: Any delay is not your fault and cannot be used as evidence of gross negligence.
- FCA regulation: All UK banks, building societies, and fintech payment firms must operate the scheme. The FCA enforces compliance.
- Landmark ruling: Case C-70/25 (Tukowiecka), 15 October 2026, establishes that reimbursement must happen first, investigation second.
Taking Action Now
The law has shifted decisively in your favour. If your bank has refused to refund APP fraud, it is almost certainly on weak grounds—especially in the light of the Tukowiecka judgment and the FCA's mandatory scheme. The worst move you can make is to accept the refusal and move on. Banks rely on consumer passivity; once you push back with the law on your side, many will reconsider.
Start by drafting a formal complaint that cites the Payment Services Regulations, the FCA's guidance, and Tukowiecka. If your bank's response remains unsatisfactory, escalate to the FOS without hesitation. The FOS is free, independent, and has the power to order your bank to pay. With thousands of APP fraud cases now working through the ombudsman system, precedent is also building in your favour.
To save time and ensure your complaint letter is legally watertight, use Paybacker's AI complaints generator to create a formal letter citing exact UK law in 30 seconds. Your first three letters are free—no credit card required. Whether you send it yourself or use our tool, the evidence is clear: your bank's refusal is likely unlawful, and you have every right to recover your money.
Need help with this? Paybacker generates the letter in 30 seconds.
Our AI writes complaint letters citing exact UK consumer law. Free to try — 3 letters per month.
Start free